Butt Plugs, Find Your Perfect Fit

Some days call for a simple shape. Others call for a little sparkle, texture or vibration. Explore butt plugs in different sizes, materials and styles, from smooth silicone designs to polished metal, glass and playful tails. Find the shape that catches your eye, then check the measurements to see whether it is your kind of fit.

181 products

Save $40.00
Satisfyer Plug-ilicious 2 – App-Controlled Rumble, Your Way
Satisfyer Plug-ilicious 2 – App-Controlled Rumble, Your Way Sale price$69.95 Regular price$109.95

3 colours
Save $7.00
Cheeky Charms Small Butt Plug with Pink Heart Jewel
Cheeky Charms Small Butt Plug with Pink Heart Jewel Sale price$24.95 Regular price$31.95
Save $45.00
The Vibe Cock, Ball & Anal Stimulator
The Vibe Cock, Ball & Anal Stimulator Sale price$97.95 Regular price$142.95
Save $48.00
SXE Roger Butt Plug Remote Vibrating & Slapping Prostate Dildo
SXE Roger Butt Plug Remote Vibrating & Slapping Prostate Dildo Sale price$81.95 Regular price$129.95
Save $12.00
Petite Sensations Teazer Butt Plug with Bullet Vibrator
Petite Sensations Teazer Butt Plug with Bullet Vibrator Sale price$34.95 Regular price$46.95
Save $6.00
ToDo Butt Plug Sweet Bunny Rabbit Tail White
ToDo Butt Plug Sweet Bunny Rabbit Tail White Sale price$21.95 Regular price$27.95
Save $41.00
Ass Master 4.5in Butt Plug TitanMen
Ass Master 4.5inch Butt Plug TitanMen Sale price$140.95 Regular price$181.95
Save $7.00
Orb Rounded Butt Plug Black Anal Adventures
Orb Rounded Butt Plug Black Anal Adventures Sale price$23.95 Regular price$30.95
Save $25.00
Tailz Black Bunny Tail Butt Plug | The Love Shop
Black Bunny Tail Butt Plug – Cute Tail, Rippled Metal Plug Sale price$39.95 Regular price$64.95
Save $34.00
Satisfyer Deep Diver App-Controlled Butt Plug – Double the Pleasure
Satisfyer Deep Diver App-Controlled Butt Plug Double the Pleasure Sale price$74.95 Regular price$108.95

2 colours
Save $65.00
Satisfyer Sweet Seal App Control Vibrating Butt Plug – Custom Pleasure
Satisfyer Sweet Seal App Control Vibrating Butt Plug Sale price$39.95 Regular price$104.95

2 colours
Save $45.00
Silicone Anal Butt Plug Trainer 3 Piece Set Green
Silicone Anal Butt Plug Trainer 3 Piece Set In Teal Sale price$64.95 Regular price$109.95
Small round gem metal butt plug with silver finish and red decorative gem
Small Round Gem Metal Butt Plug 7cm, A Little Sparkle Behind You Sale priceFrom $17.95

7 colours
Save $5.00
Small Butt Plug Pink Crystal Jellies
Small Butt Plug Pink Crystal Jellies Sale price$23.95 Regular price$28.95
Save $2.00
Butt Plug Small Black
Butt Plug Small Black Sale price$16.95 Regular price$18.95
Save $54.00
Airhole Finned Butt Plug Platinum Silicone Medium Black
Airhole Finned Butt Plug Platinum Silicone Medium Black Sale price$145.95 Regular price$199.95

Available sizes: Medium
Save $40.00
Warhead B-10 Butt Plug 10 inch Dildo Gun Metal
Warhead B-10 Butt Plug 10 inch Dildo Gun Metal Sale price$85.95 Regular price$125.95
Save $19.00
Secret Kisses Glass Butt Plug Wide Handblown 3.5 inch
Secret Kisses Glass Butt Plug Wide Handblown 3.5 inch Sale price$45.95 Regular price$64.95
Save $24.00
Avant P4 Power Play Silicone Butt Plug
Avant P4 Power Play Silicone Butt Plug Sale price$55.95 Regular price$79.95
Save $10.00
Cheeky Charms Large Butt Plug with Pink Heart Jewel
Cheeky Charms Large Butt Plug with Pink Heart Jewel Sale price$31.95 Regular price$41.95
Save $32.00
Cheeky Charms Metal Butt Plug 3 Piece Kit with Teal Jewel
Cheeky Charms Metal Butt Plug 3 Piece Kit with Teal Jewel Sale price$69.95 Regular price$101.95
Save $9.00
ToDo Large Butt Plug Classic Comfortable Blue
ToDo Large Butt Plug Classic Comfortable Blue Sale price$29.95 Regular price$38.95

Available sizes: Large
Save $15.00
Cheeky Charms Anchor Butt Plug Small with Clear & Teal Jewel
Cheeky Charms Anchor Butt Plug Small with Clear & Teal Jewel Sale price$39.95 Regular price$54.95
Save $4.00
Silver Metal Medium Butt Plug with Red Ruby Heart Crystal
Silver Metal Medium Butt Plug with Red Ruby Heart Crystal Sale price$19.95 Regular price$23.95

More To Explore
Tap to browse

Shop Small Butt Plugs Shop Jewel Butt Plugs Shop Vibrating Butt Plugs Shop Anal Beads Shop Prostate Massagers

Butt Plugs for Your Own Kind of Play

A little sparkle, a softer silicone shape or the smooth feel of metal: butt plugs can bring plenty of personality to a toy collection. The Love Shop’s anal plugs range from compact designs to fuller favourites, with vibrating butt plugs and decorative styles adding their own twist. This is about discovering the kind of detail that makes you curious.

Small Details That Change the Mood

A jewel plug has the appeal of a private finishing touch. A vibrating plug brings a buzz to familiar play, while a smooth non-vibrating design keeps the focus on shape and feel. Different styles suit different moods, from quiet solo time to an evening you have been looking forward to sharing.

A Favourite Worth Coming Back To

Explore silicone butt plugs, metal plugs and playful designs that feel at home beside your other favourites. The best addition is one you genuinely want to spend time with, at a size that feels comfortable for you. Add your preferred anal lubricant and make space for an unhurried night in.

Checkout Your Way – Fast, Safe & Secure