Small Butt Plugs, Less Size, Plenty of Possibility

Prefer a slimmer shape or a more compact fit? Explore small butt plugs in silicone, metal and glass, with smooth, textured and vibrating options. Choose a single plug or a set that includes a smaller piece, then compare the actual measurements rather than relying on the word small alone.

56 products

Save $4.00
Small Metal Butt Plug with Tourmaline Heart Crystal Gold
Small Metal Butt Plug with Tourmaline Heart Crystal Gold Sale price$19.95 Regular price$23.95
Save $3.00
ToDo Miniature Size Butt Plug Brilliant Pink
ToDo Miniature Size Butt Plug Brilliant Pink Sale price$17.95 Regular price$20.95
Save $6.00
Cheeky Charms Small Butt Plug with Rainbow Jewel
Cheeky Charms Small Butt Plug with Rainbow Jewel Sale price$23.95 Regular price$29.95
Save $7.00
Cheeky Charms Small Butt Plug with Pink Heart Jewel
Cheeky Charms Small Butt Plug with Pink Heart Jewel Sale price$24.95 Regular price$31.95
Save $7.00
Cheeky Charms Small Butt Plug with Rainbow Heart Jewel
Cheeky Charms Small Butt Plug with Rainbow Heart Jewel Sale price$25.95 Regular price$32.95
On sale
Cheeky Charms Pink Small vibrating metal butt plug with matching remote
Cheeky Charms Remote Vibrating Metal Butt Plug, A Little Spark Sale priceFrom $123.95 Regular price$133.95

3 colours · Available sizes: S, M

Save $32.00
Cheeky Charms Metal Butt Plug 3 Piece Kit with Teal Jewel
Cheeky Charms Metal Butt Plug 3 Piece Kit with Teal Jewel Sale price$69.95 Regular price$101.95
Save $7.00
Cheeky Charms Small Butt Plug with Red Heart Red Jewel
Cheeky Charms Small Butt Plug with Red Heart Red Jewel Sale price$25.95 Regular price$32.95
Save $15.00
Cheeky Charms Anchor Butt Plug Small with Clear & Teal Jewel
Save $15.00
Cheeky Charms Anchor Butt Plug – Small, Jewel-Swap Base
Cheeky Charms Anchor Butt Plug – Small, Jewel-Swap Base Sale price$39.95 Regular price$54.95
Save $25.00
TriPlugs 3 Piece Butt Plug Training Kit Rainbow
TriPlugs 3 Piece Butt Plug Training Kit Rainbow Sale price$59.95 Regular price$84.95
Save $52.00
SXE Cooper Butt Plug Vibrating Remote Anal Rimming Simulator
SXE Cooper Butt Plug Vibrating Remote Anal Rimming Simulator Sale price$116.95 Regular price$168.95
Save $13.00
Petite Sensations Butt Plug Velvety Soft with Bullet Vibrator
Save $12.00
Petite Sensations Butt Plug Bubbles with Bullet Vibrator
Petite Sensations Butt Plug Bubbles with Bullet Vibrator Sale price$34.95 Regular price$46.95
Save $12.00
Petite Sensations Teazer Butt Plug with Bullet Vibrator
Petite Sensations Teazer Butt Plug with Bullet Vibrator Sale price$34.95 Regular price$46.95
Save $33.00
Avant Vibrotize Silicone Mini Anal Vibe Fuchsia Pink
Avant Vibrotize Silicone Mini Anal Vibe Fuchsia Pink Sale price$71.95 Regular price$104.95
Save $30.00
White Fluffer Glass Butt Plug With Bunny Tail | The Love Shop
White Fluffer Glass Butt Plug With White Bunny Tail Sale price$49.95 Regular price$79.95
Save $25.00
Tailz Black Bunny Tail Butt Plug | The Love Shop
Save $20.00
Fluffy Bunny Tail Butt Plug White By Tailz | The Love Shop
Fluffy Bunny Tail Butt Plug White By Tailz Sale price$34.95 Regular price$54.95
Small metal butt plug with purple heart-shaped decorative gem at the flared base
Small round gem metal butt plug with silver finish and red decorative gem
Save $15.00
Quickie Kit Anal - Exciting Booty Play
Quickie Kit Anal - Exciting Booty Play Sale price$38.95 Regular price$53.95
Save $20.00
Anal Adventures Platinum Silicone Prostate Massager
Anal Adventures Platinum Silicone Prostate Massager Sale price$49.95 Regular price$69.95
Save $40.00
Puppy Play Set incl Gag, Tail Butt Plug and Collar
Puppy Play Set incl Gag, Tail Butt Plug and Collar Sale price$84.95 Regular price$124.95

Small Butt Plugs, A Little Purchase with Plenty of Charm

Not every favourite needs to be a statement size. Small butt plugs bring compact shapes, decorative touches and understated designs to anal play, making a little addition feel personal rather than overwhelming. A smooth silicone plug or a small jewelled style can earn its place through the details you enjoy.

The Appeal of Keeping It Compact

There is something lovely about a toy that feels manageable in your hand and easy to picture among your favourites. Smaller anal plugs can appeal to curious shoppers as well as experienced users who simply prefer a modest size. Preference does not have to follow a progression.

A New Little Favourite

Explore petite butt plugs for your own downtime or a shared purchase you have been considering. Shape, material and actual measurements make each design different, so the collection offers more than a single idea of small. Find the one that catches your eye, bring a favourite lubricant and enjoy keeping the occasion comfortably your own.